Is Ben Roethlisberger a Corridor of Famer? The case for vs Steelers QB being anchored in Canton

Ben Roethlisberger’s profession is over. The longtime Steelers starter has formally stop after taking part in for the staff in all however one sport of the 2021 NFL season. He helped lead the staff to a 9-7-1 report, however they had been knocked out by the Chiefs 42-21 within the first spherical of the 2022 NFL Playoffs.

Roethlisberger was the principle starter for the Steelers for 18 seasons. He began his profession as a backup however rapidly stepped in for the Steelers, posting a 13-0 undefeated report within the common season as a rookie. From there he rose to change into one of many NFL’s finest and most constant quarterbacks and led the Steelers to 2 Tremendous Bowl victories.

The previous few seasons haven’t been fairly for Roethlisberger as damage and age have robbed him of his as soon as high-level abilities. As such, he rides into the sundown and has racked up extra wins than every other quarterback in Steelers historical past.

Roethlisberger has gathered quite a few awards and accolades all through his NFL profession. Will he get one other one by being elected to the Professional Soccer Corridor of Fame? We cannot formally know for not less than 5 years, however the case for him doing so appears robust.

GREER: For those who take a look at Huge Ben’s all-time nice passing numbers

The case for Ben Roethlisberger making the Corridor of Fame

For those who break down Roethlisberger’s Corridor of Famer fall by taking a look at how he compares to the typical Corridor of Famer quarterback, he appears to be like like a shoo-in.

After all, since Roethlisberger’s call-up in 2004, the NFL has change into a way more passing-friendly league. However even accounting for that statistical inflation, his performances are nonetheless according to the typical Goldjacket quarterback.

Except for the dearth of an All-Professional nod, Roethlisberger definitely appears to be like like a Corridor of Famer. This argument is just supported while you evaluate him to a handful of Corridor of Famers in his place.

Ben Roethlisberger statistics

Professional Soccer Reference has a useful metric referred to as “Similarity Scores” that determines how comparable a participant’s profession at any given place was to a different participant at that place. a few of the gamers paired with Roethlisberger, it is simple to image him as a Corridor of Fame sort participant.

John Elway; Dan Marino, Joe Montana; Terry Bradshaw. These are just some of the names which are thrown out when contemplating Roethlisberger’s profession. And as you possibly can see, he compares favorably to all 4 within the Corridor of Famers.

Roethlisberger could not have the identical All-Professional honors as these passers, however his stats and wins converse for themselves. It is also value noting that he is steadily confronted off in opposition to the likes of Tom Brady, Peyton Manning, Brett Favre, and Aaron Rodgers, all present or future Corridor of Famers, so his competitors has been stiff.

Some could scoff on the concept of ​​evaluating Roethlisberger to those legends as a result of he performed in a much more becoming NFL than they did. That is a good argument, so it is essential to place him within the context of his newer Corridor of Famer friends.

There are three present Corridor of Famer quarterbacks who’ve performed since 2000. They’re Manning, Brett Favre and Kurt Warner. That is how Roethlisberger beats these three passers-by.

Once more, you possibly can definitely argue that Roethlisberger falls brief in accolades, being the one member of the group to not rating a number of All-Professional appearances. Additionally, every of the opposite quarterbacks has received MVP not less than twice — Warner has two, Favre has three, and Manning has 5. Roethlisberger does not actually have a Tremendous Bowl MVP to his identify.

Nonetheless, Roethlisberger’s passer ranking and total wins are akin to his high-end friends, and he ranks within the prime 10 for all-time landing passes and prime 5 for passing yards. He additionally has quite a few NFL information, together with the league report for many 500-yard passing video games (4). As such, his numbers are worthy of induction into the Corridor of Fame, even when he falls brief within the All-Professional and MVP classes.

The case in opposition to Ben Roethlisberger is inducted into the Corridor of Fame

Trying on the numbers as an entire, Röthlisberger is a reasonably straight ahead Corridor of Famer. Nonetheless, there are two components that would maintain him from getting votes within the early levels of his Corridor of Fame eligibility.

Roethlisberger has declined during the last three years of his NFL profession. He was nonetheless able to delivering correct passes to his receivers, however his skill to throw deep passes and stretch defenses was virtually non-existent. That is largely attributable to an elbow damage he by no means actually recovered from at the beginning of the 2019 season.

The late-career relapse is nothing new for quarterbacks who keep within the league previous 15 years, however Roethlisbergers has been notably notable because the Steelers’ offense has plummeted and faltered since their 11-0 begin to the 2020 NFL season suggested. The lingering picture of Roethlisberger throwing checkdowns, struggling sacks and searching motionless could lead on some Corridor of Famer voters to think about different gamers forward of Roethlisberger, regardless of his career-long accomplishments. Count on the bias of actuality that may impression voters.

Ben Roethlisberger rape case

The opposite a part of this equation has to do with the off-field incidents that dogged Roethlisberger early in his profession. Most notably, he was charged with sexual assault in Milledgeville, Georgia in 2010. The sufferer, then a 20-year-old pupil at Georgia School & State College, claimed Roethlisberger raped her at a nightclub after inviting her and her pals to the membership’s VIP space.

Roethlisberger denied the incident – though he admitted to having been in touch with the lady in query – and a rape package carried out on the sufferer didn’t yield sufficient male DNA to create a profile. Finally, District Lawyer Fred Vibrant introduced that no expenses could be filed in opposition to Roethlisberger, a transfer partially influenced by the sufferer, who acknowledged she didn’t need an “intrusive” trial expertise.

Though the sufferer requested to not go to trial, she didn’t retract her allegation.

The NFL suspended Roethlisberger six video games for violating the NFL’s private conduct coverage. It was later decreased to 4 video games.

Though Roethlisberger was not charged or discovered responsible of rape or sexual assault, some voters may nonetheless think about this incident when evaluating Roethlisberger’s Corridor of Fame case. The Professional Soccer Corridor of Fame has no strict pointers for Corridor of Fame eligibility or an ethics clause that will forestall Roethlisberger from being inducted. So voters will make their very own choices about methods to consider Roethlisberger’s checkered historical past off the sector.

MORE: Who might be the Steelers’ QB of the long run?

Will Ben Roethlisberger be inducted into the Corridor of Fame?

Chances are high that Roethlisberger will finally be anchored within the canton, even when some voters select to not vote for Roethlisberger due to his off-field troubles. The true query is whether or not it’s going to materialize when it may be anchored for the primary time in 2027.

However due to the dearth of a morality clause, these entitled to vote will vote in favor of Roethlisberger in the long run. He has the numbers to be inducted into the Corridor of Famer and his on-field report is among the many finest in 20 years. So it appears probably that the good Steelers will discover their option to Canton at some point.